Book review: “Machine, Platform, Crowd – Harnessing our Digital Future”
“Machine, Platform Crowd” tries to summarize what in the author’s view are the currently most important changes that will impact both, individuals and companies going forward:They call it the “Triple Revolution” consisting of:
- The emergence of machines (Robots, AI)
- The evolution from Products to Platforms
- The increasing importance of the Crowd vs. the “core”
In the first part they look at the emergence of what is often called “big data” and “Machine Learning”. They argue that we are still in the early phase of this development but that progress is made with accelerating speed. Together with similar developments in robotics and 3D printing, this could have widespread implications. They compare the current stage to the “Cambrian Explosion” where a lot of different new forms are born but where it is still not clear where this actually will end.
The second part of the book deals with Digital Platforms and how many of these platforms (Air BnB, Uber, Apple App Store etc) were taking over markets in surprisingly short time period from traditional “product” companies (i.e. Nokia etc.). Many of those platforms succeed by “unbundling” products and then combine it in new ways (Netflix, Spotify etc.). User interfaces are essential for succesful platforms and many of these platforms are “two-sided”, meaning that you have two distinctive different groups using the platforms (for instance at Uber: taxi drivers and guests). Online-to-Offline (O2O) platforms are often more difficult to scale than purely digital ones as the physical side of the platform often cannot grow in the same speed as the digital one.
The final part deals with what they call the “Emergence of the crowd”. The internet allowed the creation of self organized organizations like Linux or Wikipedia to have a real impact in areas that were previously dominated by corporations. They also look into how Bitcoin and Blockchain work. Their opinion is that there won’t be a fully autonomously run organizations as there will always be the problem of incomplete contracts and residual rights on assets. This means that you cannot foresee everything what will happen in the future and that you will need some sort of authority to decide what happens if unexpected scenarios unfold.
I found “Machine, Platform, Crowd” a very interesting and important book. It brings together current developments which in combination could really change everything we know about work, business and society profoundly and within a relatively short period of time.
Clearly one can discuss some of their conclusions, but I think no one will be able to claim that one should just ignore all this because in some areas the impact is just too obvious.
For me this book is a “must read” for every fundamentally oriented investor.
Learnings for investors
For me there are two major learnings in this book:
- For traditional industries it really is important to pay attention if the respective industry is “attacked” by a platform business. You can have the best “traditional moat” in the universe but if a platform becomes successful, the dynamics of this industry will completely change.
- As we are still in the early stages of this process, it is not clear that the currently dominating platforms will do so for very long. A lot of people now try to get on board and are buying stocks like Google, Amazon, Apple and Facebook because they have now understood a little bit how they work and conclude that they will dominate their field forever. In my opinion this could turn out to be a quite expensive mistake as there is so much happening right now and currently dominating players could be replaced by something much better if they are not super attentive. There is no reason why there won’t be any new players that unbundle what the current big players have created and “disrupt” them as they have disrupted more traditional players.
In terms of platforms threatening exceptional moats, what are your thoughts (assuming you have any on the matter) on Mr. Market recently implying that Netflix’s platform is worth more than Disney excluding ESPN?
Is a streaming platform on the whole worth in excess of the enduring content that has practically impossible to replace mindshare? Methinks this is a fad that will pass, since a platform isn’t as irreplaceable as content. Thoughts?
My impression is that Netflix is not only a platform, it’s also making (good) content. They managed to get the flywheel running and reinvest all their subscription (platform) proceeds in new, exclusive content. You’re right, Disney has got a huge moat of “historical” content. But, Mr. Market estimates that Netflix is filling up that moat faster than Disney can widen it (to use another famous metaphor). Whether that is correct? No idea.
I have no clue how to value Netflix. However some observation point to a structurally change in how Millenials consume media.
But Netflix is clearly one for the “too hard” pile.
Reaidng your article I would caution that those companies who look like winners today at such an early stage will most likely be not the long term winners,
Thank you very much for this important book review, I couldn’t agree more with you on your 2 major learnings.
I am convinced the Digital Transformation of our society is the biggest investment chance in the next 20-30 years. This is why I started my own high-tech-investing-blog last year. Just recently I wrote (in German) about how to identify the 3 categories of “Digital Leaders” who will be able to grow their enterprise value as a consequence: https://www.high-tech-investing.de/single-post/2018/01/23/In-die-Gewinner-der-Digitalen-Transformation-investieren
Btw: this is not only an investment case for tech companies – there will be winners of Digital Transformation in basically every sector. The challenge is to pick the right companies at the right time.